New answers tagged

0

According to all that's been said and done, one must assume (an educated assumption therefore) Gimli went with Legolas to the West, regardless if to Valinor or one of the off-shore isles. The "West" has always been a place of paradise and everlasting, this would include the Islands off the coast of Vailor, otherwise, why even go when you can live in Middle ...


3

From his Letters: No. 135 -- I am at last after three weeks incessant labour of the most exacting and dreariest sort (college related work just finished)...and also (if I can) finding somewhere else to live and moving! This charming house has become uninhabitable --- unsleepable-in, unworkable-in,rocked, racked with noise, and drenched with fumes. ...


7

Chapter II of Book Six, The Land of Shadow, where Frodo and Sam are trekking across Mordor itself is probably your best bet. The text does make it clear that they only see the northern region of Mordor where the mines, forges and gathering armies are, though. Some examples from the chapter: Upon its outward marges under the westward mountains Mordor was a ...


0

It's very possible that Saruman bred the northern men/women with orcs, creating the Uruk-hai. He had a long time in which to accomplish this, so, especially if more than one Uruk-hai was born at a time, or if "pods" were used, like in the movie, and they "magically" grew very quickly, so, there wasn't as long to wait, then that could explain it. Saruman can'...


3

Based on pages on the wikis' own descriptions of themselves and each other, and especially this self-history, I notice that the first one (the Gateway) is the larger in terms of content (over 11,500 vs ~6,500 entries) and community. In fact, the people surrounding both wikis had decided to merge about a decade ago, but Wikia (the company hosting the second ...


-1

It sunk into the sea, and was wiped out. Compare the first map with the last one. U can see on the second map the sea starts at the blue mountains. angband lay beyond that. I think utumno lay next to the ice bay


1

With the passing of CJRT, I believe the answer will now have to be 'no'. I left this open in case it was eventually addressed somewhere, but without a discovery of some very obscurely published commentary we can only surmise or infer from the existing HoME content.


13

The Tolkien Estate still holds the rights to everything aside from the film rights J.R.R. Tolkien sold in the 1969 United Artists deal and the TV rights sold to Amazon in 2017. This is independent of Christopher Tolkien, who actually stepped down as one of its directors in 2017. Among the remaining Directors/Board Members of the Estate are Christopher ...


-1

It's what it's supposed to do, it breaks off in the victim and then the rest dissolves while the broke bit turns the victim into a wraith over time, without anyone being aware untill it's too late I imagine it was just luck that Aragorn sees it before it dissolves and thus knew how to slow the process and get Frodo to the elves.


-2

Actually, it mentions that the gaffer was taught by his cousin Holmand Greenhand how to garden, and used his experience to work for the owners of Bag End. It is also mentioned that Samwise took over the work when his dad was too old to continue. Heck, they even live on the hill itself, in Number 3 Bagshot Row, just below Bag End itself!


24

Gandalf is first made aware of the Nine in June of T.A. 3018 While investigating some danger that Gandalf had forebode, he chanced upon a member of his Order Radagast. Radagast had journeyed for Rosgobel on the borders of Mirkwood to find Gandalf to provide him of information that the nine were abroad again. At the end of June... I... journeyed along the ...


14

The Nine were in Mordor whilst Sauron was in Dol Guldur. Sauron was driven forth from Dol Guldur by the White Council during the Hobbit (which is why Gandalf doesn't accompany the party through Mirkwood). The Ringwraiths and others had been preparing for his return to Mordor. When Gandalf tells Frodo about the Ring, he doesn't know about the Ringwraiths but ...


2

Meriadoc Brandybuck According to the Lord of the Rings's Prologue, Meriadoc was the author of many books, and one of the most important was Herblore of the Shire, where he details the history and origins of the Hobbit tradition of smoking Pipe-weed. A small part of this book was included in the Prologue itself with the title Concerning Pipe-weed, and was ...


4

It's impossible to say for sure when Frodo first used the Ring, but there are hints which in the end point to a pretty clear conclusion. First, shortly after the Party when Bilbo leaves Bag End and Frodo first gets the ring, Gandalf speaks to Frodo to tell him he also is leaving. The relevant parts of the conversation goes: 'Then I forgive you. [for ...


1

Frodo puts the Ring on, by accident, at the Prancing Pony Inn, when he falls off the table at the end of his song about the Man in the Moon. The second time is indeed at Bombadil's House and the third time on Waethertop. Galadrile tells him, after he looked into her mirror: "Only thrice have you set the Ring upon your finger since you knew what you possessed"...


1

At the very least, Saruman was able to research the fact that the ring was lost in the river. Gandalf tells the story about the last meeting of the Council of Wizards at Elrond's gathering: 'Some here will remember that many years ago I [Gandalf] myself dared to pass the doors of the Necromancer in Dol Guldur, ... 'But we were too late,... Then he ...


4

To add to the answers that explain why "it [was] named in the North Isildur's Bane", there was one other case where the name was used: the dream that came to Faramir and (once) to Boromir. In that case, you may as well ask who sent the prophetic dreams (the Valar? Eru himself?) or how they knew what would happen. The recipients didn't know what it meant, ...


22

In the Unfinished Tales there is the brief story of The Disaster of the Gladden Fields in which the events are told of how Isildur and his sons together with some of the top soldiers of Arnor were wiped out, as well as how the tale made it to Arnor and Rivendell (but apparently not Gondor, unless much later in shortened or garbled form, maybe) It's mostly ...


0

The original script refers to it as a "culvert". SETTLE ON: FRODO and SAM in a FILTHY CULVERT.. SAM twitches in a RESTLESS SLEEP. But FRODO is awake . . . His hand trails down to the CHAIN around his NECK ... A SUDDEN HISS! FRODO quickly hides the RING as GOLLUM peers at them with GLEAMING EYES. Typically these are used to channel a river or a ...


1

Sauron was defeated in the War of the Last Alliance. With nearly all of his power stored in the Ring, Sauron was vanquished when Isildur cut the Ring from his finger. After the battle, Elrond advised Isildur that he should destroy the Ring, but Isildur decided to keep it. After settling the affairs in the South, he took the Ring with him when he went ...


50

Who knew what Isildur's Bane was? Not Boromir: 'Isildur's Bane is found, you say,' said Boromir. 'I have seen a bright ring in the Halfling's hand; but Isildur perished ere this age of the world began, they say. How do the Wise know that this ring is his? Boromir probably knew that Isildur took Sauron's Ring, but almost certainly didn't know it ...


Top 50 recent answers are included