22

When Hermione, Ron and Harry tell Hagrid that Severus Snape is trying to steal the Stone, Hagrid replies that he is one of the teachers protecting the Stone.

HARRY: Hagrid, we know he's after the Stone. We just don't know why.
HAGRID: Snape is one of the teachers protecting the Stone. He's not about to steal it.

In the book, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, this makes sense, but it totally does not make any sense in the movie! Why? Snape's challenge was actually not shown in the movie!

After the chess game, Hermione stays with Ron (because he is hurt). According to the book, Hermione should leave Ron alone and go with Harry to solve Snape's challenge with the potions. Since that was not presented in the movie, it looks like Hagrid lied about Severus being one of the teachers protecting the Stone.

Is there any valid explanation for this?

21

As a trusted teacher, he was likely involved in protecting the Stone in other ways as well.

Snape seemed to be actively involved in protecting the Stone in ways other than the potions riddle. He went to check on the Stone when he got his leg mauled by Fluffy, which was left in the movie.

“Snape was holding his robes above his knees. One of his legs was bloody and mangled. Filch was handing Snape bandages.

‘Blasted thing,’ Snape was saying. ‘How are you supposed to keep your eyes on all three heads at once?” - Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Chapter 11 (Quidditch)

enter image description here

In addition, he could have helped plan the defenses, or given ideas to Dumbledore for how best to protect the Stone.

Even in the book, the potions riddle isn't the only thing he contributes to protect the Stone. He's suspicious of Quirrell, is told by Dumbledore to keep watching Quirrell:

“You see what you expect to see, Severus,’ said Dumbledore, without raising his eyes from a copy of Transfiguration Today. ‘Other teachers report that the boy is modest, likeable and reasonably talented. Personally, I find him an engaging child.’ Dumbledore turned a page, and said, without looking up, ‘Keep an eye on Quirrell, won’t you?” - Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 33, (The Prince's Tale)

And confronted Quirrell about where his loyalties lie.

“… d-don’t know why you wanted t-t-to meet here of all p-places, Severus …’

‘Oh, I thought we’d keep this private,’ said Snape, his voice icy. ‘Students aren’t supposed to know about the Philosopher’s Stone, after all.’ Harry leant forward. Quirrell was mumbling something. Snape interrupted him. ‘Have you found out how to get past that beast of Hagrid’s yet?’

‘B-b-but Severus, I –’

‘You don’t want me as your enemy, Quirrell,’ said Snape, taking a step towards him.

‘I-I don-t know what you –’

‘You know perfectly well what I mean.’

“An owl hooted loudly and Harry nearly fell out of the tree. He steadied himself in time to hear Snape say, ‘– your little bit of hocus pocus. I’m waiting.’

‘B-but I d-d-don’t –’

‘Very well,’ Snape cut in. ‘We’ll have another little chat soon, when you’ve had time to think things over and decided where your loyalties lie.” - Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Chapter 13 (Nicolas Flamel)

In addition, he's the one sent to check on the Stone when his leg is mauled by Fluffy.

  • 9
    For a question about something specific to the movies, you may want to rely less on book quotes. – ibid Sep 6 '17 at 20:15
12

Here's my speculation.

Explanation #1 (most likely): Snape's challenge is done off-screen. Simply put, Snape's Potions-based riddle was still in place but wasn't shown in the film. Book-readers know what his challenge was, so the whole thing was hand-waved.

Explanation #2: Snape, as a teacher, is a de facto protector. This is a more in-movie answer. Hagrid may have been operating under the assumption that hiding the Stone at Hogwarts makes Snape and the other faculty members co-protectors by default.

Explanation #3: Snape played some other special role in the Stone's protection. Also an in-movie answer. Hagrid has a penchant for saying too much, doing so two other times in the same movie. If Snape had had some other hand in the Stone's protection (say, by having placed it in the Gringott's vault to begin with), this was Hagrid letting it slip.

  • As per the OP, explanation #1 isn't correct because the movie has Hermione stay in the chess room. – ibid Sep 6 '17 at 19:54
  • 2
    @ibid Nope, she goes to send Dumbledore an owl, just like in the book. "Take care of Ron. Then, go to the owlery. Send a message to Dumbledore. Ron's right...I have to go on." – The Dark Lord Sep 6 '17 at 20:02
  • @TheDarkLord - it doesn't have her advance past the chess room. – ibid Sep 6 '17 at 20:09
  • 3
    @ibid True. She leaves with Ron, just at an earlier stage. Harry could still have gone through the potions challenge off-screen by himself, though (even if he wouldn't have Hermione to help him like he does in the book). – The Dark Lord Sep 6 '17 at 20:13
  • 7
    @TheDarkLord: Harry could still have gone through the potions challenge off-screen by himself -- Probably wouldn't have had much need for movies 2-8 in that case ;-) – tonysdg Sep 7 '17 at 2:55

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.