The Sith adhere to the Rule of Two: one master and one apprentice. The apprentice is taught that once they surpass their master, they must take his (her?) place by killing them. In this way, the Sith order increases in power through a Darwinian-like process of attrition.

This means that the Sith cultivate an extreme (if somewhat twisted) form of altruism. The master willingly sacrifices his own life by training an apprentice who will ultimately kill them. All for the greater good (evil?) of the Sith order.

To willingly submit himself to such a harsh requirement, there must be some goal that the Sith master values higher than their own life. It can't simply be the desire for power or domination. If you were that sort of person you would want to enjoy your power, ruling the galaxy etc. You wouldn't train an apprentice who would take it all from you at the first opportunity.

So the Sith must have some higher goal than that. What is the goal that they are devoted to? And was Palpatine on his way towards fulfilling that? If Palpatine were successful in becoming immortal then there would be no more Sith after him. The Rule of Two would cease to operate: nobody could kill him, hence there could be no future Sith Lord more powerful than him.

Does this mean that Palpatine expected the Sith order to culminate in his own person, or was he opting out?

(Yes I know this is really two questions but I believe they are related).

1 Answer 1


Legends answer.

The objective is for the Sith to survive. Darth Bane recognized that the disciples of the Dark Side will always want more:

"I can't accept what Lord Kaan preaches," he confessed. "He says we are all equals, but if all are equal, then none can be strong."


"Do not believe everything Kaan says," she warned, and he could hear the naked ambition in her voice. One to embody the power, the other to crave it. "Once the Jedi are destroyed, many of his followers will discover that some of us are more equal than others."

From Darth Bane: Path of Destruction

So, Darth Bane was aware that the Dark Side would pit its disciples one again another as they were craving for more power. The problem there was: a lot of weaker Sith would work together to kill a strong one and with that, they'd weaken the Siths.

He was absolutely convinced of this and with that, he indoctrinated his apprentice, who in turn then again indoctrinated their apprentice with the thought and so on. Plus, having an apprentice gives you power up to the point where you are betrayed. So it is a normal thing to have an apprentice.

Palpatine was not the first to crave for immortality. Darth Plagueis was Sidious master and he already craved immortality. And with becoming nearly immortal, he wouldn't betray the Rule of Two. The objective of the rule is for the Sith to become stronger. If Palpatine had become immortal, always learning more about the Force and becoming more powerful, he'd have fulfilled the ultimate objective of the rule of two: making sure that the Sith survive and grow more powerful.

  • The goal can't have simply been survival. If it were, then it would make more sense to have lots of Sith, so that whatever happened some would survive. The Rule of Two means putting all your eggs (thousands of years of Sith lore) into two baskets. What if the Master and the Apprentice both killed each other?
    – Batperson
    Feb 22, 2020 at 19:30
  • Likewise, power for its own sake does make sense as a personal motivation but not for an organisation which needs to persist through generations and demands its members sacrifice their lives in the process of perpetuating it.
    – Batperson
    Feb 22, 2020 at 19:33
  • That's what the brotherhood of Darkness tried to change, but it was already usual with the old Sith that they were killed by their students. It is the Dark Side of the Force. And all tried to change this, Plagueis was the first to succeed, only to be killed by his student (Palpatine) just afterwards. That's maybe the tragedy of the dark side, you become arrogant and think you can overcome this. You need a student to serve and do the menial tasks, but in the end, you're overcome.
    – Shade
    Feb 23, 2020 at 13:30
  • 2
    Bane was so convinced of this Rule of Two that he even considered getting a new student when she (Darth Zannah) didn't try to take over the power. And once Darth Zannah became the master, she began to look for an apprentice to learn from her and then kill her. If you'd like to know more about this, I can highly recommend the Darth Bane Novels
    – Shade
    Feb 23, 2020 at 13:33
  • 1
    They have one rule that is followed: One to embody the power, the other to crave it. Every other rule would just hinder them in the acquisition of power.
    – Shade
    Feb 24, 2020 at 8:21

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.