6

Why didn't the Earth army (and possibly navy) attempt to resist the coup of the Earth king? Then, by extension, attack the Fire Nation as they arrived to occupy the city? We see the group go through dozens of palace guards in order to reach the king, where are they now? What about the troops guarding the walls?

I would think the army would be able to at least overthrow the Dai Li.

Or is it simply just poor leadership by the Earth kingdom?

2 Answers 2

11

There were actually TWO coups of Ba Sing Se depicted during the series. The first was covert, while the second was more of a bloodless invasion.

The Dai Li Coup

Years before Aang & his friends visited the city of Ba Sing Se, the leader of the Dai Li - the city's police force - had begun working to erode the Earth King's power and enhance that of the Dai Li. By the time Aang had arrived, the Earth King was little more than a figurehead, and all of the REAL power in the city belonged to Long Feng, the head of the Dai Li. Feng had manipulated the city to such an extent that nearly all members of the Dai Li were loyal only to him, the Earth King had no idea what things were like outside of the palace, and the city populace itself was too scared of the Dai Li to do anything about the situation. The Council of Five eventually learned of the coup, but by then it was too late. In essence, Long Feng had become the Earth King in all ways but the title & throne itself.

In fact, Feng was so confident in his control of the city, he felt little need to address an invasion attempt by the Fire Nation. Unfortunately for him, he underestimated the resourcefulness of the Avatar and his friends, ultimately losing his position (AND his freedom) when his duplicity was exposed to the actual Earth King.

The Fire Nation Coup

Even after his arrest, Feng maintained the loyalty of the Dai Li. Although their power had been greatly diminished by the actions of the Avatar, the Dai Li still had a fair amount of control over the city as its police force. However, after striking a bargain with Princess Azula of the Fire Nation, Feng soon found himself losing the Dai Li's loyalty to Azula instead.

Once she secured the loyalty of the Dai Li, Azula quickly launched plans to take over the city from within. By the time her coup was finished, she basically had only to open the gates and let her father's army inside. Both the city's populace as well as its limited military put up some small measure of resistance, but any such threats were quickly eliminated by the combined forces of the Dai Li and the Fire Nation troops.

Summary:

As you can see, neither coup really offered the Earth King or his military the chance to resist. By the time they realized the first one was happening, it was done. During the second coup, they were simply out-matched and had little chance of success.

2

As we see in the show, the Dai Li is the elite, well trained, morally bankrupt security force in Ba Sing Se. There is no war in ba sing se, and as such, no standing army within the capital. Other kingdoms within the greater earth kingdom have already fallen, like ohmasu, and a good portion of the Earth Kingdom soldiers are petty thugs. Since the earth king is pretty much a puppet, controlled by the head of the Dai Li, which is still in power, and the Dai Li has taken out the higher level army generals in ba sing se, there is 1, no coordination that could be formed to fight the internal coup, and 2, they likely have no idea that it happened.

The Dai Li have control of the capital, of the Army, and regularly kidnap and brainwash vocal disidentes that don't follow their scripted news.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.