Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackSciFi/status/349817304252555264
deleted 173 characters in body
Source Link
BESW
  • 17.9k
  • 3
  • 95
  • 103

Star Trek: The Next Generation/Doctor Who: Assimilation2 is a pretty coolgreat comic, but it does some pretty weird stuff with the Cybermen. Some of it, like turning the Cybermen into a hivemind, are carried on from poor decisions in New Who proper.

But what's the deal with the Cybermen in the flashback?

Kirk and Spock shooting Cybermen. Note earmuffs.

They have the enormous earcovers and smooth lines of the Mondasian Cybermen from early Who:

Cyberman from the 1968 story The Invasion. Note earmuffs.

On the other hand, the Cybermen we see during Picard's time...

Borg eyepatches are the latest in Cyberwear.

...have the distinctive cheekbones and smaller earpieces of Cybus Cybermen from "Pete's World."

Cybermen from the 2006 story Army of Ghosts. Note cheekbones and smaller earcovers.

Within the story, it is made very clear that the Cybermen in both the TOS and TNG eras are part of the same bridgehead force from the Whoniverse into the Trekverse, but by all visual cues they shouldn't be; Mondasian and Cybus Cybermen are entirely different creatures with different origin stories and different weaknesses and strengths. Besides, since the Cybermen are using time travel to do this, shouldn't all the Cybermen in the story hail from roughly the same time period?

  • Why are the Mondasian and Cybus Cybermen shown working together, or as part of the same group? Is this just a visual gag akin to the (highly amusing) art style change in the flashback, or is there some kind of thought behind it?

(The allergy to gold would've been a strong indication that they're all Mondasian, but Nightmare in Steel provides the exact same problem: Cybus-looking Cybermen --though we don't know where they come from-- with an allergy to gold which the Doctor can really only know about because he thinks they're Mondasian.)

Although meta-level answers might be necessary, answers that boil down to "timey-wimey" or the MST3K mantra will be considered unhelpful.

Star Trek: The Next Generation/Doctor Who: Assimilation2 is a pretty cool comic, but it does some pretty weird stuff with the Cybermen. Some of it, like turning the Cybermen into a hivemind, are carried on from poor decisions in New Who proper.

But what's the deal with the Cybermen in the flashback?

Kirk and Spock shooting Cybermen. Note earmuffs.

They have the enormous earcovers and smooth lines of the Mondasian Cybermen from early Who:

Cyberman from the 1968 story The Invasion. Note earmuffs.

On the other hand, the Cybermen we see during Picard's time...

Borg eyepatches are the latest in Cyberwear.

...have the distinctive cheekbones and smaller earpieces of Cybus Cybermen from "Pete's World."

Cybermen from the 2006 story Army of Ghosts. Note cheekbones and smaller earcovers.

Within the story, it is made very clear that the Cybermen in both the TOS and TNG eras are part of the same bridgehead force from the Whoniverse into the Trekverse, but by all visual cues they shouldn't be; Mondasian and Cybus Cybermen are entirely different creatures with different origin stories and different weaknesses and strengths. Besides, since the Cybermen are using time travel to do this, shouldn't all the Cybermen in the story hail from roughly the same time period?

  • Why are the Mondasian and Cybus Cybermen shown working together, or as part of the same group? Is this just a visual gag akin to the (highly amusing) art style change in the flashback, or is there some kind of thought behind it?

(The allergy to gold would've been a strong indication that they're all Mondasian, but Nightmare in Steel provides the exact same problem: Cybus-looking Cybermen --though we don't know where they come from-- with an allergy to gold which the Doctor can really only know about because he thinks they're Mondasian.)

Although meta-level answers might be necessary, answers that boil down to "timey-wimey" or the MST3K mantra will be considered unhelpful.

Star Trek: The Next Generation/Doctor Who: Assimilation2 is a great comic, but what's the deal with the Cybermen in the flashback?

Kirk and Spock shooting Cybermen. Note earmuffs.

They have the enormous earcovers and smooth lines of the Mondasian Cybermen from early Who:

Cyberman from the 1968 story The Invasion. Note earmuffs.

On the other hand, the Cybermen we see during Picard's time...

Borg eyepatches are the latest in Cyberwear.

...have the distinctive cheekbones and smaller earpieces of Cybus Cybermen from "Pete's World."

Cybermen from the 2006 story Army of Ghosts. Note cheekbones and smaller earcovers.

Within the story, it is made very clear that the Cybermen in both the TOS and TNG eras are part of the same bridgehead force from the Whoniverse into the Trekverse, but by all visual cues they shouldn't be; Mondasian and Cybus Cybermen are entirely different creatures with different origin stories and different weaknesses and strengths. Besides, since the Cybermen are using time travel to do this, shouldn't all the Cybermen in the story hail from roughly the same time period?

  • Why are the Mondasian and Cybus Cybermen shown working together, or as part of the same group? Is this just a visual gag akin to the (highly amusing) art style change in the flashback, or is there some kind of thought behind it?

(The allergy to gold would've been a strong indication that they're all Mondasian, but Nightmare in Steel provides the exact same problem: Cybus-looking Cybermen --though we don't know where they come from-- with an allergy to gold which the Doctor can really only know about because he thinks they're Mondasian.)

Although meta-level answers might be necessary, answers that boil down to "timey-wimey" or the MST3K mantra will be considered unhelpful.

edited body; edited title
Source Link
BESW
  • 17.9k
  • 3
  • 95
  • 103

Were Are the cybermenCybermen in Assimilation²'s flashback"Assimilation²" Mondasian or Cybus?

Star Trek: The Next Generation/Doctor Who: Assimilation2 is a pretty cool comic, but it does some pretty weird stuff with the cybermenCybermen. Some of it, like turning the cybermenCybermen into a hivemind, are carried on from poor decisions in New Who proper.

But what's the deal with the cybermenCybermen in the flashback?

Kirk and Spock shooting cybermen. Note earmuffs.Kirk and Spock shooting Cybermen. Note earmuffs.

They have the enormous earcovers and smooth lines of the Mondasian cybermenCybermen from early Who:

Cyberman from the 1968 story The Invasion. Note earmuffs.

On the other hand, the cybermenCybermen we see during Picard's time...

Borg eyepatches are the latest in cyberwear.Borg eyepatches are the latest in Cyberwear.

...have the distinctive cheekbones and smaller earpieces of Cybus cybermenCybermen from "Pete's World."

Cybermen from the 2006 story Army of Ghosts. Note cheekbones and smaller earcovers.

Within the story, it is made very clear that the cybermenCybermen in both the TOS and TNG eras are part of the same bridgehead force from the Whoniverse into the Trekverse, but by all visual cues they shouldn't be; Mondasian and Cybus cybermenCybermen are entirely different creatures with different origin stories and different weaknesses and strengths. Besides, since the cybermenCybermen are using time travel to do this, shouldn't all the cybermenCybermen in the story hail from roughly the same time period?

  • Why are the Mondasian and Cybus cybermenCybermen shown working together, or as part of the same group? Is this just a visual gag akin to the (highly amusing) art style change in the flashback, or is there some kind of thought behind it?

(The allergy to gold would've been a strong indication that they're all Mondasian, but Nightmare in Steel provides the exact same problem: Cybus-looking cybermenCybermen --though we don't know where they come from-- with an allergy to gold which the Doctor can really only know about because he thinks they're Mondasian.)

Although meta-level answers might be necessary, answers that boil down to "timey-wimey" or the MST3K mantra will be considered unhelpful.

Were the cybermen in Assimilation²'s flashback Mondasian?

Star Trek: The Next Generation/Doctor Who: Assimilation2 is a pretty cool comic, but it does some pretty weird stuff with the cybermen. Some of it, like turning the cybermen into a hivemind, are carried on from poor decisions in New Who proper.

But what's the deal with the cybermen in the flashback?

Kirk and Spock shooting cybermen. Note earmuffs.

They have the enormous earcovers and smooth lines of the Mondasian cybermen from early Who:

Cyberman from the 1968 story The Invasion. Note earmuffs.

On the other hand, the cybermen we see during Picard's time...

Borg eyepatches are the latest in cyberwear.

...have the distinctive cheekbones and smaller earpieces of Cybus cybermen from "Pete's World."

Cybermen from the 2006 story Army of Ghosts. Note cheekbones and smaller earcovers.

Within the story, it is made very clear that the cybermen in both the TOS and TNG eras are part of the same bridgehead force from the Whoniverse into the Trekverse, but by all visual cues they shouldn't be; Mondasian and Cybus cybermen are entirely different creatures with different origin stories and different weaknesses and strengths. Besides, since the cybermen are using time travel to do this, shouldn't all the cybermen in the story hail from roughly the same time period?

  • Why are the Mondasian and Cybus cybermen shown working together, or as part of the same group? Is this just a visual gag akin to the (highly amusing) art style change in the flashback, or is there some kind of thought behind it?

(The allergy to gold would've been a strong indication that they're all Mondasian, but Nightmare in Steel provides the exact same problem: Cybus-looking cybermen --though we don't know where they come from-- with an allergy to gold which the Doctor can really only know about because he thinks they're Mondasian.)

Although meta-level answers might be necessary, answers that boil down to "timey-wimey" or the MST3K mantra will be considered unhelpful.

Are the Cybermen in "Assimilation²" Mondasian or Cybus?

Star Trek: The Next Generation/Doctor Who: Assimilation2 is a pretty cool comic, but it does some pretty weird stuff with the Cybermen. Some of it, like turning the Cybermen into a hivemind, are carried on from poor decisions in New Who proper.

But what's the deal with the Cybermen in the flashback?

Kirk and Spock shooting Cybermen. Note earmuffs.

They have the enormous earcovers and smooth lines of the Mondasian Cybermen from early Who:

Cyberman from the 1968 story The Invasion. Note earmuffs.

On the other hand, the Cybermen we see during Picard's time...

Borg eyepatches are the latest in Cyberwear.

...have the distinctive cheekbones and smaller earpieces of Cybus Cybermen from "Pete's World."

Cybermen from the 2006 story Army of Ghosts. Note cheekbones and smaller earcovers.

Within the story, it is made very clear that the Cybermen in both the TOS and TNG eras are part of the same bridgehead force from the Whoniverse into the Trekverse, but by all visual cues they shouldn't be; Mondasian and Cybus Cybermen are entirely different creatures with different origin stories and different weaknesses and strengths. Besides, since the Cybermen are using time travel to do this, shouldn't all the Cybermen in the story hail from roughly the same time period?

  • Why are the Mondasian and Cybus Cybermen shown working together, or as part of the same group? Is this just a visual gag akin to the (highly amusing) art style change in the flashback, or is there some kind of thought behind it?

(The allergy to gold would've been a strong indication that they're all Mondasian, but Nightmare in Steel provides the exact same problem: Cybus-looking Cybermen --though we don't know where they come from-- with an allergy to gold which the Doctor can really only know about because he thinks they're Mondasian.)

Although meta-level answers might be necessary, answers that boil down to "timey-wimey" or the MST3K mantra will be considered unhelpful.

added 16 characters in body
Source Link
BESW
  • 17.9k
  • 3
  • 95
  • 103
Loading
added 302 characters in body
Source Link
BESW
  • 17.9k
  • 3
  • 95
  • 103
Loading
Source Link
BESW
  • 17.9k
  • 3
  • 95
  • 103
Loading