The Comedian is portrayed as a cynical, nihilistic, and sadistic thug, using unnecessary violence and even committing crimes himself, like his attempted rape of the original Silk Spectre and his murder of his Vietnamese lover.

Once employed by the government, he is heavily implied to have been the assassin of JFK.

Two panels from Watchmen, showing the Comedian joking about his lack of an alibi for the JFK assassination

Given all that, what was his motivation for joining the Minutemen as a crime fighter?

  • 8
    I'll see if I can dig of evidence of it between the original and prequel comics, but my impression was that he started out an idealist, fighting on the docks to eliminate crime, got jaded, and continued fighting because he found he enjoyed fighting and hurting people. Working with the Minutemen meant more opportunities to mix it up with opponents.
    – FuzzyBoots
    Jun 21, 2018 at 13:57
  • 8
    ... because he's a sadistic thug.
    – Adamant
    Jun 21, 2018 at 13:57
  • 1
    I don't really know how to prove this formally, but I was left with the impression that he enjoyed the irony of being a "crimefighter" who committed crimes himself on a regular basis. That's at least part of why he's called The Comedian, right? He's laughing at how screwed up the world is, that a person like himself can exist in it.
    – Steve-O
    Jun 22, 2018 at 13:25
  • "attempted"? It's been a while but I always thought it went farther than attempted.
    – Paul
    Jun 24, 2018 at 20:18

2 Answers 2


I believe a bit of questioning the premise of the question is in order here: did he really want to become a crimefighter? According to Before Watchmen: Minutemen he was hardly more than a thug before he joined the Minutemen:

There's also the bit from Watchmen #4 ("Watchmaker"), where Jon recounts his experience in Vietnam with Blake:

In addition to a thug, he was also a sadistic maniac. One can imagine a scenario where he starts as a guy beating up people who just happen to be some kind of baddies. He then goes on to join the Minutemen, probably because the job description fitted his tastes, and maybe also because that would place him on the right side of the law, and get him a bit of money.

Next the Minutemen disband, and he goes on doing government's dirty work (basicaly same thing he used to do). He sort of continues to do crimefighting, as seen in the scene where he and Night Owl II address a protest. There we see his attitude towards the "American Dream", which also demonstrates his broader philosophy (nicely outlined in detailed answers here).


I find some modicum of explanation in the watchmen when comedian shoots the pregnant woman while dr. manhattan stands and watches. The comedian then rails at dr. manhattan that he could have stopped the woman from dying with a single thought yet hadn't. The comedian perceived reality at a level where he saw only 2 options; laugh at it all or cry. He wasn't the crying type.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.