40

I am re-watching Ss 1-5 of the new Doctor Who, waiting for S6 to come to Netflix... and I just finished S3, with Martha Jones. At the end of her season, she chooses to leave the Doctor, to return to earth, and get her doctorate and pursue a "normal" life.

This got me wondering: how many companions, through all the 11 Doctors, chose to leave, as Martha did, as opposed to how many were 'forced' to leave (one way or another) as Rose Tyler and Donna Noble were? Was Martha alone in this decision, or were there others?

I'd have to say, if I had the opportunity to travel with the Doctor, I can't imagine ever voluntarily leaving!

  • 2
    I dunno, maybe I am a coward, but the thought of traveling with The Doctor scares the willies out of me. :) – geoffc Sep 6 '11 at 17:50
  • 3
    Does the Brigadier and the original unit crew count as "companions"? – Doug Spoonwood Sep 6 '11 at 19:51
51

By my reckoning (some are questionable), there have been 20.5 voluntary, 11.5 forced, 8.5 deaths and 1 unknown (Ace). If you consider death a forced exit, then it's around a half forced and a half voluntary (most often for love).

1st Doctor

  • Susan wants to leave (she falls in love), but decides that she can't (because she has to look after her grandfather). The Doctor forces her out because he knows that it's best.
  • Barbara and Ian were kidnapped by the Doctor. They leave voluntarily (the Doctor opposes it) when they find a way to get home.
  • Vicki falls in love and leaves voluntarily.
  • Steven leaves voluntarily in order to lead a peace effort.
  • Katarina dies (sacrifices herself to save the Doctor).
  • Sara Kingdom (dubiously a companion) dies by accident.
  • Dodo leaves voluntarily (with no real reason given).

5.5 voluntary exits, 0.5 forced, and 2 deaths.

2nd Doctor

  • Polly and Ben join the 1st Doctor by accident. They voluntarily leave when they have a chance to resume their normal lives.
  • Jamie and Zoe are forced to leave by the Time Lords. (Jamie potentially came back in "Season 6b", and his second departure is unknown; given that the Doctor still ends up exiled to Earth, Jamie likely was forced to leave again).
  • Victoria leaves voluntarily to live a normal life (much the same as Martha)

3 voluntary exits, and 2 forced.

3rd Doctor

  • Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart played a similar role to a companion, but the Doctor left him, so doesn't really count for this question (and he died well after this). The same is true for Sergeant Benton and Mike Yates.
  • Liz Shaw never travelled in the TARDIS, but was essentially a companion. She voluntarily left UNIT (with no real reason given).
  • Jo leaves voluntarily (she falls in love).

2 voluntary exits.

4th Doctor

3 voluntary exits, and 2 forced.

5th Doctor

3 voluntary exits, and 2 deaths.

6th Doctor

1 forced exit.

7th Doctor

  • Mel leaves voluntarily for another type of travel.
  • We don't know about Ace, because the series was cancelled before we found out. Apparently the intent was for her to leave (presumably voluntarily) to train to become a Time Lord.

1 voluntary exit, 1 unknown.

8th Doctor

  • Grace declines to travel with the Doctor (a voluntary exit before anything even starts!), although it's questionable whether she can be considered a companion.

0.5 voluntary exits.

War Doctor

The War Doctor does not have any on-screen companions (I do not consider the Moment a companion), although he does in other media.

0 exits.

9th Doctor

  • Adam Mitchell was forced out by the Doctor after not even one episode.
  • Jack Harkness is left behind, although after Utopia he voluntarily returns to Torchwood.

2 forced exits.

10th Doctor

  • Rose is forced to leave (although she does actually stay with a Doctor).
  • Mickey Smith leaves voluntarily (multiple times!).
  • Martha leaves voluntarily to live a (somewhat) normal life.
  • Donna is forced to leave because she cannot survive knowledge of the Doctor.

The 10th Doctor also had several 'one-off' companions - most lists include them as companions although they never travelled with the Doctor and only appear in a single episode. None of them can be considered to have "left" the Doctor, although two do die (Astrid Peth and Adelaide Brooke), one of whom probably would have travelled with the Doctor.

2 voluntary exits, 2 forced.

11th Doctor

  • Amy and Rory leave unwillingly after a Weeping Angel sends Rory to 1930s New York, and Amy willingly chooses to be sent back along with him. The Doctor reading their tombstone creates a fixed point in time, so the Doctor is unable to rescue them.
  • River is similar to a companion, although we don't really see much of her travelling with the Doctor. Her final appearance in The Husbands of River Song is after her official "death" in "Forest of the Dead".

In my opinion Craig Owens isn't a companion, although he plays a similar role in an episode.

3 deaths.

12th Doctor

  • Like the Brigadier, Danny Pink never travels with the Doctor, but does play a similar role as a companion. He is killed when he is hit by an automobile, turned into a Cyberman, and eventually sacrifices himself to destroy the rest of the Cybermen, and sacrifices his return journey from the Nethersphere to send back a boy he killed during his time as a soldier.
  • Clara Oswald is killed, then brought back between 2 heartbeats using Time Lord technology. She tricks the Doctor in forgetting about her, then leaves voluntarily for an adventure together with Ashildr in a stolen TARDIS. She will eventually have to return to her final moment so she can die.
  • Bill leaves to explore the universe with Heather, voluntarily (her prior cyber-conversion doesn't seem to count as a death given the circumstances), although her only other choice was returning to Earth, not continuing to travel with the Doctor (much like Romana).
  • Nardole is instructed by the Doctor to lead a group of people to safety, which he does. I consider this a forced exit.

Ashildr is similar in companionship to Craig Owens: the Doctor is involved in multiple episodes with her, but she never actually travels with the Doctor in his TARDIS. In my opinion, she is not a companion.

1.5 deaths, 0.5 voluntary exits, 2 forced exits.

13th Doctor

We do not yet know how Graham, Yasmin, and Ryan will leave the Doctor.

The above only includes companions who appeared on TV episodes (and the 8th Doctor movie); those that appear only in spin-off media (audio dramas, novels, etc) are not included. The TARDIS Index File has more information about the companions, including the fate of these additional companions.

  • 3
    If you're going to include Adelaide Brooke as a companion, I think you'd have to include Lady Christina de Souza as well. Both were 'one-off.' While Adelaide did take one trip in the Tardis, it was only a one-way trip never intended for more. And Christina did work much more closely with him than Adelaide. – Tango Sep 7 '11 at 2:58
  • 1
    @TangoOversway I wasn't listing the "one off" companions (Wilfred Mott, Jackson Lake, and Rosita Faris would be included too) - I just mentioned the two that died, which Lady Christina did not. I did count Astrid (as a 0.5) since she was asked to become a companion, but I didn't count Adelaide (just listed her). – Tony Meyer Sep 7 '11 at 4:27
  • 1
    Can you really count what happened to her in her first appearance as a spoiler? :) – KutuluMike Aug 16 '12 at 22:27
  • 2
    @MichaelEdenfield Given that it occurs at the end of that episode, and is the emotional centrepiece of much of their relationship, yes. – Tony Meyer Aug 23 '12 at 9:48
  • 1
    The Amy and Rory entry could be updated, post-season 7. – Paul D. Waite Oct 7 '14 at 23:22
4

Actually it's my impression that most of the companions left by choice.

Quite often they chose to stay behind after an adventure with the Doctor. For example, Leela chooses to stay on Galifrey with Andred; Adric chooses to stay and try to divert the spaceship from crashing into prehistoric Earth; Romana chooses to stay in E-Space along with K9; Nyssa decides to stay on Terminus; Peri marries King Yrcanos (Brian Blessed!); Jo Grant decides to marry an environmentalist and go and work in the Amazon... and so on.

In fact just about the only companion I can think of that was forced to leave was Sarah Jane, who was (as she later complained to the Tenth Doctor) dumped off when the Fourth Doctor is summoned back to Galifrey.

2

Companions usually ceased travelling with the Doctor for one of three reasons. Either they chose to leave, the Doctor ordered them to leave, or an external force compelled them apart.

I don't know the details of every companion, I mean, there were alternate timelines that weren't canon and so on. Have you checked the following link:

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Companion

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.