1

If, when a person is in Narnia, time does not pass in the real world and children who visit Narnia enter it one at a time (as in a queue), then after the first child crosses over how do the other 3 enter Narnia as well?

I ask this because after the first child enters, if the time in the real world is stopped then the other 3 children should not be able to do anything.

  • 1
    It's clear that on a short timescale, time in Narnia and our world run in sync -- if someone enters Narnia five seconds after someone else, then they arrive five seconds after as well. It's only on longer timescales that time runs at different rates. If talking mice don't bother you then neither should this. – Mike Scott Aug 4 '14 at 18:42
2

I think you may be misinterpreting here. The narrator says, in Prince Caspian (Chapter 1),

While [the Pevensie children] were in Narnia they seemed to reign for years and years; but when they came back through the door and found themselves in England again, it all seemed to have taken no time at all.

That, as I interpret it, does not mean that time stopped "in the real world" while the children were in Narnia, but simply that the children's "real-world" re-entrance time was the same as their "real-world" exit time.

That being the case, all that the "time does not pass in the real world" means is that fundamentally, time in Narnia is disconnected (at least in the large scale) from time on Earth. As Edmund says in Chapter 3:

"You know what we were puzzling about last night, that it was only a year ago since we left Narnia but everything looks as if no one had lived in Cair Paravel for hundreds of years? Well, don't you see? You know that, however long we seemed to have lived in Narnia, when we got back through the wardrobe it seemed to have taken no time at all?"

"Go on," said Susan. "I think I'm beginning to understand."

"And that means," continued Edmund, "that, once you're out of Narnia, you have no idea how Narnian time is going."

Which means, then, that if the one child (Lucy) enters, and then the other three after her, there's no necessary connection between when they enter and when she enters—but it doesn't mean that they can't do anything because "time is stopped".

  • then based on the answers, I got the following doubt after entering first child, could happen she had to wait seconds / minutes / days / months / years until the next child enter? – Only a Curious Mind Aug 4 '14 at 19:03
  • 2
    I don't see that there's any requirement for that. Edmund enters through the wardrobe presumably a few seconds after Lucy does, and then all four children at the same time. There's nothing in the books to indicate that the wardrobe was "closed" for any given time before the next child could enter. – Matt Gutting Aug 4 '14 at 19:27
  • @MattGutting In fact, the books made a strong point that the wardrobe was not closed properly while the children were in Narnia (except for when Edmund met the White Witch); but he and Lucy left before anyone else entered that time – Izkata Aug 5 '14 at 1:07
8

Simply there is no time correlation between Narnia and Earth. At each instance of a visit to Narnia time flows differently depending on Aslan's personal touch. We have instances where 60 years was a minute and instances of an hour being a minute. We have instances where Lucy enters the wardrobe and minutes later in the real world Edmund also enters the wardrobe that it has only been hours in Narnia. We have instances where they enter Narnia in back to back days and it's only days in Narnia, or with a week span in the real world with 1 year in Narnia. 1 years after The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe it's close to 2000 years later. With these inconsistencies we can understand that there is no correlation to real world and Narnia and as such we cannot speculate at all.

  • Would it be possible to add some actual references for all those different cases? – Mr Lister Aug 5 '14 at 5:37
  • sorry im usually on here at work without my books, the majority of that is from the lion witch and the wardrobe, then theres about a 2000 year gap in about 1 year for prince caspian. which is also funny because while its about 1940 when lion witch and the wardrobe is set, after that it takes pirates from 400 years ago (the telmarines) and puts them into narnia. So narnia's future can access our past. lol – Himarm Aug 5 '14 at 12:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.