2

In Rebels Season 4 Episode 13 Vader is about to kill Ahsoka

when she disappears into the thin air, and goes to the "world between worlds". The Emperor finds out she is alive, and presumably later tells that to Vader.

But later both the Emperor and Vader are confident that Kenobi died on Death Star 1, although

he also just vanished, like Ahsoka, leaving only his clothes behind.

Why didn't they learn from this experience that apparent death could be deceiving when powerful Force users are concerned ?

  • 1
    1. Because it's a retcon, 2. I'm tempted to close this as per our Future Works Policy as this or a similar issue will likely be resolved in a later episode. – Edlothiad Mar 1 '18 at 7:59
  • 4
    You're pardoned. A retcon is not bad storytelling but simply "a piece of new information that imposes a different interpretation on previously described events, typically used to facilitate a dramatic plot shift or account for an inconsistency." This is then, certainly a retcon. As you've provided a different interpretation on previously described events. Secondly, given that we don't have an answer in the current canon, and the series isn't over, it likely does breach our Future Works Policy, as it will likely be covered in a later piece of canon. – Edlothiad Mar 1 '18 at 8:21
  • 1
    It does seem like this is wide open to speculative answers and we're only likely to get a definitive answer from a future episode (of course, it's equally likely they'll never address it). – delinear Mar 1 '18 at 8:38
  • 1
    Also - it's not a retcon (Ashoka being saved) because Filoni is involved in all aspects of Rebels production. Ashoka's fate has been a matter of fan speculation, but Filoni has been cagey about it since her apparent death. – NKCampbell Mar 1 '18 at 14:48
  • 1
    ...there is no evidence as of yet that Vader knows she is alive. Additionally - you are confusing retcon with an intended story point. Filoni planned this for Ashoka from the begining of that story - starwarsunderworld.com/2018/02/… - it would be a retcon to say that Kenobi and Yoda's disappearance is due to the being pulled into the world between worlds by another force user, but that isn't what is happening. What happened with Ashoka is (afawk) different, part of the original intention of the writer, and thus, not a retcon – NKCampbell Mar 1 '18 at 18:22
2

Aside "vanishing", both situations had little in common

When Obi-Wan vanished, he had just been struck by a Vader's lightsaber, and left behind in his place were his robes and his own lightsaber. His body literally disappeared from within.

Contrast that to Ahsoka, who from Vader's perspective, had half an arm literally reach over from out of thin air to grab her, pulling her back into nothingness, along with all her possessions.

Vader knew his strike hit in the first scenario, and likewise knew it did not in the second. He knew someone intervened in the second, but had nothing to indicate likewise in the first. Weird for sure, and a little familiar, but too different to jump to the conclusion that he must have been rescued.

But how could they be sure?

I mean, sure, maybe someone reached through the floor and grabbed Obi-Wan's leg and pulled him down out of his robes without Vader seeing. But what then? Do Vader and the Emperor have no way of being certain?

At least as far as what they know to be possible from Ahsoka's situation, they actually do have a way to check. The Emperor could just do what he did last time and call up the world between worlds and see if any Jedi happen to be hiding about.

This leads to two possibilities. Either 1) with the destruction of the temple, access to this space is now closed off, and the Emperor won't be able to see it, which confirms it wasn't involved. Or 2) He accesses it and sees if anyone inside, and knows again whether or not it was used. Even still, given the destruction of the temple, he'd have little reason to suspect it was even accessible or usable anyways.

But what if...

Like you mention, maybe it was some different and presently unknown means of making someone vanish. How could they be sure?

After we've exhausted ruling out the above known means of pulling off this trick, there's really no point for Vader and the Emperor to waste their time speculate further. Maybe he's alive? But probably not. If it later turns out that he is, they'll just revise their understanding of the events and attempt to learn why and how he survived. But until then Occam's razor wins out, and the most likely situation is probably the one that occurred, and he's simply dead.

All of this even still presupposing that the Emperor was unaware of Force ghosts (which seems unlikely, given his and his master's research into surpassing death). If Palpatine did know, then he already knows what happened to Obi-Wan with a great deal of certainty.

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.