9

The Borg Cube ship is obviously one such ship that has beaten a Galaxy class in single combat.

Another is the Tamarian cruiser, TNG 5x02 'Darmok'.

Also, the Husnock Warship (recreated) beat a Galaxy Class.

Has any other starship beaten a Galaxy Class in a one-on-one battle?

  • 5
    The Husnock warship probably should not count. There is no way to tell it's actual capabilities. – Xantec Apr 17 '14 at 1:10
  • 3
    Technically the Duras sisters defeated the Enterprise in a Bird of Prey, but it wasn't exactly a fair fight. Also, the Romulans disabled the engines on the Enterprise in Tin Man, but that was a sneak attack. Although the ship seemed to always be on the verge of destruction, I'm having trouble thinking of many straight up fights. Even the Jem'Hadar rammed the Odyssey to take it out. – Xantec Apr 17 '14 at 1:44
  • 1
    I don't suppose you want to count Tin Man. – Kyle Jones Apr 17 '14 at 2:49
  • 4
    A Jem Hadar ship destroyed a Galaxy-class in DS9 - the sister ship of the Enterprise. However, I think it may have been a kamikaze attack. (I only remember this because it was referenced on TVTropes.) – lunchmeat317 Apr 17 '14 at 3:24
  • 1
    So a Borg Cube, Tamarian Cruiser, Husnock Warship(), Gomtuu (Tin Man), Klingon Bird of Prey(), Jem'Hadar Attack Fighter(), and the Romulan 'Scimitar'(Sovereign Class) have all beaten a Galaxy Class or better. ()=special circumstances. Someone needs to compile this into a good answer form. Add any others that can be noted. – Morgan Apr 20 '14 at 3:54
4

I can't take credit for the complete answer here as it was developed by several worthy researchers, the results of which are collected below:

The following starships have beaten a galaxy class 'or better' Federation starship in 'mostly' 1 on 1 battle.

  • Borg Cube
  • Tamarian cruiser, TNG 5x02 'Darmok'.
  • Husnock Warship. Some argue that it was just a fabrication of Kevin Uxbridge. He obviously recreated it but I believe that it was an accurate recreation. Large enough to be seen by the naked eye as it orbited and with enough firepower to pulverize a planet.
  • Jem'Hadar rammed the Odyssey (kamikaze attack at end of 3 on 3 battle) – credit Xantec
  • Tin Man/Gomtuu. – credit Kyle Jones
  • Romulan Scimitar from 'Nemesis' beat the Enterprise E (Sovereign class) and two Romulan Warbirds at the same time. – credit Dacio

This seems to be a complete list of those ships but I seem to remember there could be one or two more that fit the criteria. The research proceeds...

  • 13
    ... if you can't take credit, why don't you make it community wiki, so that you won't take credit? – Lyndon White Apr 26 '14 at 12:42
  • Also D'deridex class warbirds seem to be superior to galaxy class as a warship. But I don't remember any direct confrontation between them. – Sinan Oct 15 '16 at 10:45
-2

(Late answer) :), imo aside from Borg Cube, almost all those instances where a galaxy class was "supposedly" beaten is because there was almost no shields up on that moment of attack either because enemy ship was cloaked or the weapon configuration was unknown to the federation standard (Jem Hadar : used phased polaron beams) ...but the point here is any ship without shield can easily be destroyed or beaten regardless whether its a galaxy class or a bird of prey, but if you are going to be hypothetical on a scenario where both are shielded and properly configured it all comes down to shield strength and regenerative capabilities and its hull strength, and since a galaxy class or any large ship has both of the qualities it will outlast a cloak capable warship like the BOP and the klingon warbird.

Setting aside Federation Standard Configurations, i'd place my bet on the Modified Voyager thanks to Seven Of Nine / One / Future Janeway for enhancing and augmenting Adaptive Shield and Anti-Borg Armor :) could probably beat any of the enemy ships mentioned

  • Hi AltOa. Thanks for contributing. We are really looking for complete, detailed, answers and this one doesn't contain enough detail to be a good answer. Speculation and 'I'd place my bet' type answers are off limits. Please do read around, and have fun contributing/ Thanks. – DJClayworth Oct 14 '16 at 18:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.