This story is about someone from the future ensuring the first atomic bomb is set off in 1945 so that the "future" would be one in which Earth would be the only source of intelligence in the galaxy. At the conclusion of the "Foundation" set of books this is what makes Trevises (?) opt for Gaia as it would unify all life in this Galaxy against any possible invaders from any neighbouring galaxy. Something not taken into account in the short story.


2 Answers 2


End of Eternity(1955) is a novel with this plot. Asimov originally wrote it as a short story, it was not published at that time, but this original was later released in an anthology called "The Alternate Asimovs"(1986)

The basic idea was that humanity never developed atomic power and space flight, but discovered time travel technology instead. Since all new developement is being spent in time travel, and since the "Eternals", a cabal of human time travelers, aim to minimize wars and dangerous technologies by altering history, humanity never develops the technologies required to leave the solar system before the whole galaxy is colonized by different races, and humanity eventually dies out in this version of history.

Ultimately, history is altered so that humanity will colonize the galaxy before any other races have the chance to develop, which also prevents the discovery of time travel and the founding of the "Eternity" cabal.

The short story apparently has a slightly different plot and in particular a different ending than the novel. Asimov himself called it weak.

  • 1
    IIRC, the plot of the short story is very different from that of the novel. In particular I don't think it included the development of the atomic bomb or mentioned alien intelligences. Oct 21, 2014 at 20:29
  • Some of the post-Asimov Foundation novels added that positronic robot terraforming machines were sent out between the Spacer era and the First Empire era to find and prepare any habitable worlds for future humans, also destroying any aliens they came across, especially pre-space flight ones.
    – jhpace1
    Jan 2, 2016 at 2:21

There is a short story with this plot called "Spell my name with as S" Some energy vertex characters (were there ever human before , it is unclear) take bets. First one of them changes history to avoid the 1945 atom bomb (and also future annihilation of the human race). Then they realise that their boss, the "Watcher" will be angry so they bring everything back to what has to be. One can find the text here:


  • 1
    That seems like the opposite of what the querent is looking for.
    – FuzzyBoots
    Oct 4, 2019 at 17:48
  • 1
    Well, yes, I am aware of that. But from perusing the site, I saw that sometimes people look for a story, and mix up some details, so the actual answer they finally do accept is the opposite of what they first asked. The question is about a short story. "End of Eternity" is a novel, and was not accepted. Nor was the "short story" version proposed by HugoRune. I just tried that one, because "someone from the future" looked like the energy vertex characters.
    – Alfred
    Oct 5, 2019 at 18:55
  • @FuzzyBoots In fact, I actually recently accepted an answer which described a story somewhat differently from the way I had originally described it, but it was my memory that was incorrect. Many details given in the answer were clear proof that the answer was indeed the one I was looking for despite the differences with what I thought I remembered.
    – Alfred
    Oct 6, 2019 at 18:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.