11

In Star Wars Episode Five, during the Battle of Hoth, numerous AT-ATs' legs were tied up by snowspeeders. From what I understand, this was a new tactic that was invented on the spot by Luke Skywalker after conventional methods to bring the walkers down (primarly lasers from the bases turrets and the speeders themselves) failed to damage the heavy armor plating. This being said, it seems as if the walker captains had no little to no knowledge of what was actually going on. Were there no hydraulic feedback mechanisms between the legs and the dashboard that would alert the pilots of the issue? Did other walker captains not understand what the rebels were trying to do? Did they just fail to communicate with the "lassoed" walker's captains to tell him to stop walking forward? Or did they underestimate the strength of the cables? Strategically speaking, the least they could have done is remain stationary and provide support from afar. Numerous possibilites come to my mind regarding this issue. But for multiple walkers to go down due to a perfectly avoidable tactic seems like a collective failure on the part of the ground forces. Was there something else going on that viewers didn't know about?

  • 3
    I seriously thought this was a "Why did the chicken cross the road?" question based on the title – user31178 Jan 17 '15 at 3:46
  • I would bet we could tie this up as a "Lucas"-ism ... just the way he wrote it, but don't know, so will leave as a comment. – Pᴀᴜʟsᴛᴇʀ2 Jan 17 '15 at 3:57
  • 1
    Part of it may be you answering it already...it was new, they didn't realize what was happening, so they couldn't combat it – The Fallen Jan 17 '15 at 4:09
  • 1
    I only remember one AT-AT going down like that, not "numerous". – KSmarts Jan 18 '15 at 0:05
  • This question never occurred to me. Very interesting. – Wad Cheber Jun 21 '15 at 0:10
6

First of all, chances are the walker crew likely would not have known how they were brought down. They just came crashing down suddenly. Although there would have been some feedback (likely) between legs and body, there wasn't really an indication of what that was. We, as the viewers, knew... but it happened so quickly. Suddenly, the crew were thrust forward into the ground. Not long after, another speeder blasts them.

Even if they would have had time to relay the message to other walkers, chances are in the heat of the battle that they wouldn't have known what the cause was.

2nd of all, the walkers had to keep advancing. The walkers were their main tactical advantage on the open plain of the snowfield. What other options did they have? Chances are the AT-ATs were used on a variety of planets and that's what was on hand.

They had to keep advancing to get close enough to disable the shield generators. They were, essentially, expendable, as long as they accomplished their mission.

  • Good answer. I guess I never considered how quickly it would have happened. However, considering this, two scenarios come into my head. Firstly, don't the AT-AT's have visuals on eachother? And secondly, why couldn't they radio in the short gap between falling and getting blasted? – Aidan Daniels-Soles Jan 17 '15 at 8:53
  • Ever been in a car crash? There can easily be a couple of minutes between airbag deployment and rational thought and action. – gowenfawr Jan 17 '15 at 15:21
  • "They were, essentially, expendable, as long as they accomplished their mission." I seem to recall that in the last book of the Jedi Academy trilogy, it is noted that stormtroopers are always considered expendable as long as they accomplish their mission. I would assume this applies to snowtroopers too. – Codes with Hammer Sep 16 '15 at 15:54
2

From a Physics perspective they couldn't stop even if they knew exactly what had happened.

Try walking when someone has tied your shoes together... or running and hitting a wire etc, you fall.

It's very hard for anything on 2 or 4 legs to "stop on a dime". The forward momentum is always going to continue in some way. If they tried to stop the outcome would be the same as the fall that occurred, the Walker would fall the same way, the movie shows the leg trying to move as a cue, but even if they tried stopping it would still move until the system could kick in to stop it. A vehicle that size on 4 legs would practically have to do a "military stop", one final step and a final foot plant to kill the momentum.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.