Before the trees, as I remember, there were two giant lamps that lit the world until Morgoth smashed them. Were these in any way supposed to be the Original Lights of the World when the Children of Iluvatar woke, and where did the light come from to light these Lamps?


History of the lamps, from the generally reliable Tolkien Gateway:

After the Valar entered the world, there was a misty light veiling the barren ground. The Valar took this light and concentrated it into two large lamps.

Aulë forged great towers on which to place the Lamps, one in the furthest north, Helcar, and another in the deepest south, Ringil. Varda filled them with light and Manwe hallowed them.

In the middle of Middle-earth, where the light of the Lamps mingled and the vegetation of Yavanna was richer, was the Great Lake and the island Almaren, where the Valar first dwelt.

The lamps were destroyed by an assault by Melkor. Their fall was cataclysmic: The symmetry of Arda was destroyed as the weight of the lamps broke continents and their fire burned the land, such that the original design of the Valar was undone forever, including Almaren. The Valar did what they could to hinder the damage and their Enemy and his hosts fled back to Utumno. As they didn't know the time and place of the Children of Eru, they were afraid to rend the Earth again.

The TL;DR version: basically it went like this.

  • Valar: Let there be light!
  • Melkor: RARGH! Kill! Smash! Destroy!

The lamps were made to light the world, and the light in them came from Varda, aka the famous Elbereth/Gilthoniel.

  • Well, those fires of Melkor already provided light. If they hadn't been so shortsighted in subduing these fires, then they wouldn't need to forge these new lamps. – JK. Sep 18 '15 at 4:23
  • Is there any thoughts on SFF:SE about whether or not the various lotr/tolkien wiki's are accepted as good sources? Because a lot of them are sourced but they are heavily written with speculation and the writers own words added in. – Edlothiad Jan 5 '17 at 16:14
  • @Edlothiad Tolkien Gateway is an exception to the usual guidelines on wiki sourcing: it's very reliable. – Rand al'Thor Jan 5 '17 at 16:16
  • Hmm, I beg to differ but hey-o. Thanks for letting me know – Edlothiad Jan 5 '17 at 16:17
  • @Edlothiad Oops, just realised that my original answer used LOTR Wikia as a source and not Tolkien Gateway. Edited. – Rand al'Thor Jan 5 '17 at 16:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.